Rude Awakening
Here I am, almost choked with tears. My pride is hurt, but I’ve had some time to think over what I’ve just learned so I feel calmer now, though the bus ride home was anything but soothing.
Julia finds me to be an incompetent teaching partner. I don’t know whether she actually used the word incompetent because I’ve yet to hear this information from her mouth. The strangest thing happened to me today.
But in order to understand today’s events, I should catch you up on the last couple of weeks and Grade 2. Ever since the show lesson for Grade 1, which was in December, Grade 1 has gone very well. Christy and I talk often and it is easy to discuss my ideas with her, as well as gain knowledge on teaching and aspects that I am otherwise weak in. Grade 2 is another matter altogether. For a while before the Spring Festival holiday, I felt that things in Grade 2 were going smoothly. I didn’t need to discuss things with Julia in detail because we were clicking really well and her disciplining and my teaching meshed perfectly…in my mind.
We returned from the holiday and everything changed. Grade 1 continued to go exceptionally well and Grade 2 suddenly became a minefield. Some days would go smoothly and others would be a complete disaster. I should mention now that I am not openly aware of what works and what doesn’t in my teaching methods. All I know is that with each day, the tides can and do change. This causes me a great deal of (potentially) unnecessary stress but I haven’t tried to change things because I figure that this is part of the territory for an untrained teacher in a classroom of 45 students of a different social background and an unknown language.
I mention this because several of the Chinese teachers and a couple of the foreign teachers have suggested time and time again to find the formula “that works” and apply it to Grade 2. But I don’t know what the formula is because I don’t function in that way. I come up with different methods for conveying the information each time and so I don’t know what works any more than I know why nothing is working.
There are two factors that contribute to the recent decay of my working relationship with Julia. First, Julia has decided to withdraw from my classes for the most part. She still shows up, but often, if feels as if she has mentally escaped the classroom. She stands in the back and chimes in only when positively necessary. I had noticed this new behavior of hers a couple of weeks ago and was very disturbed at first. Then, gradually, I came to expect it. You see, we don’t discuss the problems we’re having. Instead, we act as if everything is business as usual and get through lessons on a day-to-day basis. Her enthusiasm wasn’t very high to begin with and now, it is completely sapped. For some reason, I fear Julia, or am intensely intimidated by her and chose to avoid her at all costs. This is part of the second factor contributing to my incompetence.
And I will completely own up to my own deficiencies. Unfortunately, not only do I fear Julia and choose to avoid the problem with her, but I am aware that she wishes me to be a stronger disciplinarian and I refuse to do it. At first, at the beginning of the 1st term, I became aware of the need to rein the students in at all times. I tried being angry and ferocious (I know, ME), but it seemed ridiculous and I couldn’t get behind it in my own mind so how could the students possibly take me seriously? After a few half-hearted attempts to threaten the students into submission, I gave up altogether and Julia picked up where I had feebly left off.
Several times now, I have been ashamed at how obviously my inability to discipline has turned Julia into the bad cop, but I have a few defenses for my stance on anti-strictness. I cannot understand my students. I cannot answer their simple questions and I cannot relate to them in any way other than the puppet that speaks perfect English. They have a million and seven questions, being inquisitive and bright children, and all I can do is pick out a few words and look helplessly at Julia for translation. I can’t tell you how many times we’ve arrived in class to find a student inconsolably crying at his or her desk and Julia will ignore the student, taking the stance that it is best to leave the student to collect him or herself. She won’t even ask the nature of the grievance. This troubles me greatly. If I could communicate with the child, I would ask the reason for the tears. These children are required to study for the duration of an adult’s work schedule daily and are constantly yelled at, made examples of and ignored. It upsets me that I know little of their family backgrounds or how they act in their other classes. It seems an imbalanced request to require that the foreign language teacher make English class fun and interesting and yet keep the students in line and controlled. I’m supposed to make learning exciting and be silly and yet, when I do these things, the students are loud, talkative and boisterous. This makes Julia extremely perplexed and she barks out angrily, putting an end to the fun and leaving me in an awkward position. I suppose she thinks I should be the one yelling, but I cannot reconcile laughter and shouting in the same breath.
I’m sure she doesn’t like being the disciplinarian and that is why she has become frustrated and withdrawn, but if this is the case, why let me find out about her disappointment in such a roundabout and disconcerting manner? Why not have it out with me? I suppose she tried. Last Thursday, after an extremely unruly week with both Class A and B, she came to the office and asked to take one of my class periods. She wanted to go over something that was very important with the students and said that she didn’t want me to be there because the children, “never listen to you”. I felt as if she’d slapped me. Without having made any suggestions or discussed the problems with me beforehand, she’d simply notified me of my incompetence. She then suggested that I be more strict in class and discipline them more often. She told me of an intricate and to me, ridiculous scheme for keeping the children in line: a point system based on conduct and participation that leads to stickers that leads to a prize after a certain amount of stickers are collected. I felt like asking her if she wanted me to focus on the point system or on my lesson plans. Instead, I promised I’d think about discipline more and we left it at that. I’d even started to feel confident again because classes were going better and she had continued to be withdrawn so I felt I was gaining ground with the students.
And then today happened.
It happened in such a surprising manner that I suspect the urge to cry came from my shock and the blow to my ego. I had just finished with Kindergarten and was going to use the computer in the office to write about Kindergarten because it had been especially comical and bizarre and because I don’t have the Internet again at home. Christy happened to be at the computer and so I collected my things and was on my way out when she came over to chat with me about trivial items. And then, from somewhere deep in my subconscious, I asked a question that surprised me and seemed odd because I felt it didn’t relate to me at all. I had no idea where I was going with my line of questioning. It was as if my subconscious had a plan but had to grope in order to get my conscious in sync. I asked Christy what courses of action were available to a Chinese co-teacher if she was disappointed with her foreign teacher. I remember, as I was asking the question thinking, “Why are you asking this. This has nothing to do with your own situation. Are you trying to gain gossip on another foreign teacher?” Christy seemed surprised by my question and didn’t quite know how to respond. I continued with more questions, eventually coming to what my subconscious wanted to discuss, “Do you think Julia would approach me about a problem before going to the leaders?” And then, Christy, looking relieved and obviously having misunderstood my question said, “So she has talked to you about her disappointment with your classes?”
I felt my stomach drop. For one thing, I had eerily caught wind of Julia’s dissatisfaction without even being aware of what it was I was attempting to unearth. Christy immediately saw from my reaction that no, Julia had not talked to me. She looked worried and nervous. I tried to ease her mind by saying that I just wanted to talk about the situation and that she need not tell me what Julia had confided to her. Christy became concerned and tried to offer me advice. It was too soon in my discovery to be open to advice. I felt betrayed. Anger and defiance rose up in me at the thought of Julia withdrawing from class, a sign that she didn’t care about what happened, and then going and talking about the problem to my other co-teacher. Christy explained that Julia didn’t want to talk to me unless the problem was universal. She said that she, herself, was satisfied with me as a teaching partner and so Julia had assumed that the problem wasn’t completely with me but that it was more obscure.
And now that I’ve had time to reflect on the whole situation, I see that the problem is with me. I am no more of a disciplinarian in Grade 1 than I am in Grade 2. However, Christy and I have a very solid working relationship. She is willing to take the role that I refuse and I work hard and make sure that the lessons are strong and creative and fun. On the other hand, Julia and I hardly ever speak. Our interactions are strained at best. I am intimidated by her moods (she is often irritable and silent) and by her un-offered teaching experience. Instead of helping or suggesting ways to improve my plans she looks on from the back of the room and if she deems a point that I’ve made irrelevant, she simply doesn’t translate, leaving me afloat, scrambling to follow my apparently irrelevant point with a more appropriate one.
The upside of all of this is that I seem to have matured in a lot of ways. Why, just last year, had this sort of thing happened to me, I’d have been on the phone with the first parent to answer and I’d have cried and waited to be told how perfect I am in their eyes, worrying only about my crushed ego. Also, I find it easy to throw up my hands in melodramatic despair and shriek that all is lost in situations where I am criticized. I’m not one to work stubbornly towards a resolution unless it somehow benefits me.
But it appears that I’ve changed for the better in the last year (for the most part…) On the bus ride home, I took deep breaths and determined to resolve the situation with empathy. You see, this isn’t my life. I get to leave this particular hardship in three months and I get to choose whether or not to ever return to teaching. I also have the opportunity to train to be a teacher and to equip myself with the skills that I currently lack. On the other hand, this is Julia’s life. Each year, she must start afresh with a green foreigner. She doesn’t have any say in that foreigner’s amount of experience or training, either. And, she must work with whomever she is told to. In the meantime, she is responsible for a certain productivity from the students. She is at the beck and call of parents who feel that the foreign teacher is going too quickly in class or not calling on their child often enough.
And so, while I am not willing to begin disciplining this late in the game, I am willing to do and try whatever else Julia would like, in order to make her life easier. I also would like to be successful with my 2nd graders as I love them dearly and want them to have the best chance in English next year. And hopefully, in dealing with this problem directly, I will encourage Julia to talk face to face with her next co-teacher so as not to vent her frustrations everywhere but the source. I can only hope.
Here’s a small triumph for me tonight: I’ve managed to keep my eyes dry and I’ve managed to calm myself considerably and think rationally about my mini-trauma through thought and 2200 words. Thank goodness for self-analysis!
